Robb Watch: Handy Andy tries to save Senator Wong

There is still some hope for the ALP even though PM Turnbull is treading very carefully and producing sky high approval ratings.

The hope comes from the increasingly vigorous re-emergence of policy zombies from the Abbott government.  First there was the former PM spraying op-eds in every direction this week explaining how the AEF “Abbott Expeditionary Force” to Syria was the required bold measure that PM Turnbull could not stomach.

Now we have the Minster for National Asset Garage Sales, Mr Andrew Robb, firing spit balls at the Treasurer, Mr Morrison for displaying some wisps of common sense when it comes to flogging assetKidmans off shore to our eager currency manipulating trade rivals desperate to “export capital” to Australia.

The SMH does an excellent job of recording Mr Robb’s dissembling (click to read) on the topic.

So what are Mr Robb’s contributions to the debate?

  1.  The issue is ‘political’.  No kidding Mr Robb.  The national economy and the ownership of assets is inherently political and it is only in your fantasy world where economics is some apolitical ‘science’, Mr Robb is dangerous in the Trade portfolio simply because for ALL our trade rivals –  trade policies are intensely political and they eat ‘economics is a science‘ saps like Mr Robb for breakfast.
  2. “..always depended on foreign investment for agriculture, because no bugger here will put money into the sector…”  First, selling off local assets is not investment. It is merely a transfer of ownership. Secondly, there is no shortage of capital in Australia with $2T in super savings alone.  Thirdly, if Mr Robb is concerned about the preference of Australians to pour hundreds of billions of dollars into unproductive investments in bidding up the price of existing housing, he needs to look at the tax and other policies that Mr Howard and subsequent governments (yep Rudd-Gillard) introduced that made speculating on rising house prices the preferred ‘investment’ strategy of millions of Australians.  We have so much spare capital that we can seemingly afford to piss most of it up against the wall of the house price ponzi scheme – promoted by the FIRE sector ideological pals of Mr Robb.
  3. “I’ve heard about selling Australia forever. I just haven’t seen a farm leave the country yet.”   Who is writing your lines Comical Andy?  Sure the land cannot be shifted off shore but the profits can be shifted off shore quick smart (or through the joys of transfer pricing – never exist in Australia at all).  Plus Mr Robb is desperate to encourage fly in fly out foreign work forces so not even the wages will stay here.   Mr Robb’s lame jokes will leave the nation lame.
  4. “Mr Robb did not personally criticise Mr Morrison, but said: “We have to carry people with us….”   There is a reason for that Mr Robb, the only people who will buy the tosh you are peddling are the comatose.

With Mr Robb back on the scene trying to explain why Australians should applaud his efforts to accelerate the efforts of our trade rivals to acquire our asset base in their attempts to manipulate exchange rates via unproductive capital exports to Australia, it should be happy days for the ALP and Senator Wong.   She can back off the wrong headed campaign she launched last week and instead leave Mr Robb and his broken neo-liberal capital flow obsessions to swing in the breeze as the wind changes direction.

But unfortunately, the ALP cannot get too excited about taking advantage of the return of Mr Robb and his policy zombies as the Labor agriculture spokesman Joel Fitzgibbon is still pressing on regardless and floundering around playing the xenophobe/race card (i.e. he thinks it is discriminatory not to allow all our trade rivals exactly the same ability to “acquire” our agricultural assets and manipulate the exchange rate) and repeating the same daft idea that Australia is somehow short of the capital required to develop our agriculture industries.

“The [2012] Greener Pastures report tells us that to meet our aspirations we will need $600 billion in investment in agriculture by 2050, and as an island nation with a small population, by definition much of that will need to come from foreign sources.”

Wake up Joel, wake up Penny, wake up the ALP or you may as well set your alarm clocks and hope the Australian public gets bored of Mr Turnbull / Mr Morrison in a decade or so.

 

One thought on “Robb Watch: Handy Andy tries to save Senator Wong

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s